Well 4.5 stars, I have to try this! I can appreciate a mom and pop shop. The customers love this place, I chatted with a woman just super excited about this place, practically had everything on the menu! My opinion, the food was decent but I think 4.5 is a little stretch, sorry, that's my honest opinion. I was a little disappointed too. My spaghetti was ok, the Italian Sausage was good. The salad is just normal but the Italian wedding cookies were yummy! Overall, decent experience, it was ok. But don't let me sway you, you may love it!